This one went higher than the others in the same catagory.  Probably because of the box?

Old Ice Cream Scoop Rare Brikone Dairy Advertising SOLD 615.99 by eBay Seller genetsky  Check it out HERE

Pretty…

1865 Tiffany Medallion Sterling Silver Serving Scoop Spoon Ice Cream Server SOLD $ 331.50  by eBay Seller 69mainstreet Check it out HERE 

Very Rare Bohlig #20 Butterfly Ice Cream Scoop 1908 SOLD 285.00 by eBay Seller jenksantiques Check it out HERE 

Antique Dover NH Slicer Ice Cream Scoop Sling Blade Dual Action Works SOLD $273.00 by eBay Seller poundshort  Check it out HERE 

This one looks cool to me!

Old Unusual Flat Ice Cream Scoop Economy Paten App. For Round Sandwich Style  SOLD $250.53 by eBay Seller gbit  Check it out HERE